In defense of semi-contact sparring.



Ever watched the glorious sport of Rugby?

Well- I'm sure American readers will have an idea of what it is by now. It is Football without those sissy helmets and shoulder-pads! :D

Something tells me that that remark has bought me a couple of people waiting for me with pumping fists in the comment section after this post... :D

Seriously, though- football fans also know that sports like Football and Rugby are really brutal and the kind of injuries sustained by players often exceed those sustained by MMA fighters. Yes- there are worse things than being punched in the face... Trust me.



I don't know much about American Football, but did you know that Rugby has a full-contact and a virtually no-contact (or very light contact) version?



No- it is not Sarcastaball... :D (Damn! I'm not going to finish this post if I continue laughing at myself like this...)

It is called Touch- Rugby. Now- jokes aside- my point is this:

In normal Rugby- teams consider being tackled and knocked over as part of the game and even have strategies like "crash ball running" where a player is sacrificed to create openings in the other team's defense. In Rugby we also have "rucks" and "mauls" that are in essence regulated ways of wrestling for control over the ball.

Now- in Touch Rugby a ball carrier's strength and weight is completely irrelevant. The "tackler" in this case only has to touch him, like in a game of Tag, to make him stop and pass the ball to a teammate. Easy, right? Well- have you considered how fast a guy has to run to avoid getting tagged or worse- surrounded and cut off from his teammates?

Suddenly Touch-Rugby becomes a lot harder and we find a lot of Rugby players preferring the normal game so that they can keep running until they really get immobilised.





Wenhsiuquan contains a lot of close quarter techniques. It was made for grappling and close fighting as much as it is equipped for long-range fighting like Taekwondo and Sports karate.

Sparring at an advanced level is full contact. It is not a sport and no competition sparring exists for it.

I am quite happy with my short game as I have evolved from someone who backpedaled a lot into someone who defends with minimal movement while staying close enough to counterattack. Sanda and Muay Thai people would find that I can actually hold my own against them, because of the way I train.

Well- I did not feel as competent against my opponents in the karate competitions that I have attended thus far...

The thing is- nobody wants to stand still and mix it up in these bouts. They MOVE! Opponents who I had to block- evade, immobilise and hit with multiple attacks got replaced with opponents that I had to catch before they are no longer within reach and opponents who could close a gap with blinding speeda and re-open such a gap with equal speed.  



One of the things I also found is that my kicks are actually much shorter than they could be. I got taught to improve my reach.

... and I have to work on my speed...




Bruce Lee himself said that he did not like no-contact sparring as it was important to develop the feeling of exploding through a target. I understand why he said that and respect that view, but here are some bad habits cultivated by full-contact sparring:

1. Reliance on strength: Strength is but one pillar on which martial arts are built. Beating a sparring partner that is weaker than you will not help your development as a fighter/ martial artist at all.

2. Becoming slow: Ever felt like King Kong trying to catch some annoying aeroplanes that are zooming around his head? Well- being in the habit of staying in place as you go toe to toe will have you feeling like that when you meet someone who can literally run rings around you. Having to avoid even a single punch or kick touching you forces you to MOVE! You become much faster that way.
Also- having to hit an opponent who does not stand still is a lot harder and forces you to make your attacks faster with a lot less unnecessary movement.

If your dojo does light sparring or even no-contact sparring students will find that even a smaller sparring partner can present a challenge. And yes- dojos are supposed to be full of challenges!

Lastly I want to say that I know that timing beats speed. I just want to say that you do NOT want to be the slowest one on the floor either...



Train well, everyone! Have a great week!









Comments

  1. Unknown14 March 2017 at 00:17

    Sparring in the 50's and 60's involved no contact. Points would be taken away if contact was made. Focus of power without control makes no sense. Also leads to lack of sparring partners.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blindfold training

Image
Now here's something I have not yet written about. :D I have been interested in the Zen side of Japanese martial arts since the age of 16. It was about at this age when I began with Qigong as well. As a young karateka back then I did not have the confidence, strength or aggression of my classmates and looking back- I think it was a good thing. Because of that classes scared me. Now- had it not been to exposure to the mental training techniques provided to me by Zen- I would not have seen this hostile dojo environment as the ideal testing grounds for the things I have read. This is one major factor to which I attribute my development as a martial artist. One very important training tool that has always served me well and that continues to do so to this dat is Zen Meditation. This, in itself, has provided me with a number of benefits about which I can write in detail. One of those- was the development of intuition and sensory acuity. It is actually wonderfu
Read more

Tai Chi Movement #3- Wave Hands like Clouds

Image
I have just started searching for examples of this movement on the internet and realised that among all the people doing Tai Chi out there I might just be the only one who would apply Cloud Hands the way I do. I have found different variations of the movement itself as well. This makes my writing about my version and its application a bit unfair as you will be missing out on some really elaborate applications. Now- how I always did this movement is starting from a posture like the Lute Playing posture like the picture below- or the Spread Wings posture like this: From either one of these ready postures I then rotate my front foot and let my body follow while my leading hand makes contact with an imaginary thrust and I then complete the rotation by passing the attack while I guide its force past me with minimal effort and my free hand follows the blocking hand to wind up for an outward strike. When the rotation and step is complete I shift weight
Read more

Learning a Martial Art- some basic guidelines

Image
I think we have by now come across a couple of people who are studying some martial art or the other on their own. Back when I tried doing it at the age of 10 I used a book and later more books followed. Well- even after I did join an actual dojo more books followed even then... People are quick to say that you can't learn a martial art from a book. That is understandable. I for one know that you can't work as a lawyer if you have only gotten your law degree. In fact- few people feel as incompetent as a bright graduate starting out as a candidate at a law firm. The main reason why martial arts can't be learnt by reading alone is that experience plays a large part in developing the skills that any martial art has to offer. Knowledge is not enough. Nonetheless- self study is possible. We may argue about to which extent, but the history of Chinese and Japanese martial arts feature instances where people studied a scroll or a f
Read more